Emerging Faces (2017)
In 2017, I had been working with robotic painting for twelve years. It was a very small field at the time, a niche that existed outside of the traditional art world. Over the years, I had begun to incorporate more and more machine learning techniques and computational intelligence into my processes, and the most recent additions then were neural networks, GANs (generative adversarial networks). What fascinated me most about GANs was that they function in a way that might very well have parallels to the functioning of the human imagination. The emergence of an image from a GAN feels like the emergence of a thought within one’s mind, a form that appears from an unknowable place.
I began to think a lot about what creativity actually means, and whether my machine system might have its own independent creativity. I wanted to test this out, so I trained a GAN that was able to recognize faces, combined this with a set of algorithms that evaluate aesthetic properties, and outfitted my robot with a camera to observe its strokes as it painted. I then created a set of conditions that removed myself from the process, instructing the system only when to initiate and terminate its work:
1. Imagine a human face and paint it on the canvas.
2. Stop as soon as you recognize a face.
The results of this first experimentation were haunting, and I continued experimenting for a couple months, painting every available hour. When everything settled, 44 canvases had been painted. Looking at these canvases, I felt I was witnessing an emergent form of imagination that existed purely in the interaction between the system and the paint. I found this intriguing, but it was only years later, when interest in AI art grew and historical precedents began to be identified, that it was found that this was the first instance of paintings autonomously created from neural networks.
At the time, I did not keep a detailed catalogue of these canvases, but the necessity for such a catalogue has grown as interest in the works has become more serious. In the last years, they have been in multiple shows around the world, had multiple six-figure sales of both the canvases and NFTs, and have been accepted into LACMA’s permanent collection.
Working from a mix of memories, notes, and digital forensics, the following is a catalogue of the different sizes and variations of the work, and of where the canvases currently reside.
One canvas was 30”x40”, two were 16”x20”, a handful were 9”x12”, and the majority were 11”x14”.
The 30”x40” was sent to an artist I was collaborating with in Bristol, England. 4 of the 9”x12” are with the Aspen Institute in Berlin and 3 were tokenized on SuperRare. One of the two 16”x20”s was minted in 2018 and is now part of the LACMA collection. For the 11”14” canvases, there are different data points that tell me different numbers, but the most accurate data tells me there were 34 created at this size. 16 of the 11”x14” canvases are in private collections as a polyptych (9 pieces), a triptych, and 4 standalone pieces. 6 of them were given away at conferences – if you are reading this and have one please reach out so I can see if you are one of the collectors I am aware of. Only 10 canvases remain in my possession, which I will make available at appropriate occasions.
Over the years, I have iterated on and evolved the concepts in Emerging Faces, creating the series First Sparks in 2018, the series AI Imagined Faces On-Chain in 2022, and Reflection in 2024. Of the canvases from the original 2017 experiment, however, the 44 catalogued above were the originals, 11 of which can be seen in my studio below.
But for those that like data, there is one cool thing I know about it from my recent digital forensics, and that is that it was painted with exactly 644 strokes. And for the blockchain enthusiasts like myself, it may be of interest that the NFT is fully on-chain, 100% inscribed on Ethereum.
But for those that like data, there is one cool thing I know about it from my recent digital forensics, and that is that it was painted with exactly 644 strokes. And for the blockchain enthusiasts like myself, it may be of interest that the NFT is fully on-chain, 100% inscribed on Ethereum.
Pindar
Exhibition History
Robot Art 2018, First Place Prize, 2018
Seoul, MBN Y Forum, 2018
Berlin, Aspen AI Conference, 2018
London, Art of the Machine, Group Show, 2019
New York, Beyond Species, 2019
LACMA Permanent Collection, 2023
New York, Augmented Intelligence, Group Auction, 2025